@
MorRioghan
Quote:
Also, if I were mafia, why would I come out and try to be Town Cop? Why wouldn't I try to pretend my role was something like Doctor/Angel? It would be so much easier to make a track record. "Yeah, this night I did this, then this night I tried to save this person, etc." Or, I would come out as the town hider. That's so easy to be like, "Yep it's my role, all I do is hide in random people's houses every night."
There's absolutely nothing to it. There's no way to prove, no way to disprove, it's the perfect thing for a mafia to pretend to be. Then, you can even "come up with a theory" for the night you failed to make a kill. I do think that "Hider" is a rather applicable role to come out as, though, considering you're using it as a disguise.”
Let me ask you a question: if I was the last maf, and it was the end of the game, would I claimed a role that can’t be proven or one where I can “confirm” a player a fellow teammate investigated? If I choose the later, I could’ve just claimed to be redirected or “confirm” any roleclaim that might’ve come up before the night ended. It would be risky, but I've been in enough mafia games to not be surprised if this was the case.
Either option would’ve been possible and it’s pretty much WIFOM at this point.
Quote:
@/Skydancer It makes sense then. I believe Ember used her role as the transporter to make it so I couldn't investigate either you or her and prove that I was the Town Cop. She then chose to use "hider" because it was a role that no one could disprove that she had. It was a good excuse, something to hide behind. If I hadn't made the mistake of coming out last night with my role, I could've proven this better possibly. I made that mistake too, and she took advantage of it. She got rid of Sevlyna, who she knew was a proven townie and attacked me instead.
That's my working theory. She knew I could draw more suspicion than Sevlyna. I had already outed and confirmed Sevlyna's role.
If I was the redirector, I probably would've figured Sky must have been some kind of vig-like role since you roleclaimed. Why didn’t I attempt to make her shoot you while I “killed” Sevlyna?
“@/EmbertheSkywing @/Skydancer10
You (Ember) noticed the game was in MyLo when it went into that, which I did not. (1) You noticed off of the rolecard that the mafia would've had to be the same or equal. (2) You noticed small things like this, which could've been previous calculations that you were going through as the mafia. It's something you could've noticed from the beginning as a goal... "Only need to get the town down to an equal number and we win" Sort of deal. These are things that didn't catch my attention and I'm not sure if they caught Sky's, but you could've known from previous knowledge, that you did know from previous knowledge.[/b]”
(1) Yeah, but I have no idea if you even knew what MyLo was before I mentioned it. Stream also specifically put it on top of the bold text, I’m pretty sure she meant it to be noticed:
StormDreamer wrote on 2019-04-11 02:12:10:
It is now mylo.
Comba has been killed. They were town roleblocker.
MagykalWagykal has been killed. They were mafia rolecop.
Day 4 has begun! You may resume posting.
Day 4 will end on 00FRT, 13 April 2019. Lynch votes submitted after this will not be counted.
(2) Okay, I know this is a bit of a nitpick, but “same” and “equal” are literally the same thing. And here’s the thing about the Magy's rolecard, it was in the same post, for everyone to see. I don’t see how that automatically makes me maf.
MorRioghan wrote on 2019-04-15 10:40:36:
EmbertheSkywing wrote on 2019-04-14 19:35:06:
The funny thing, Morri, is that you're taking advantage of my disadvantage.
And the thing is, you're taking advantage of mine, the one you put on me. I still believe you're the transporter, used this to make it so you could undermine my claim, and then pin this all on me. It's a brilliant plan for a mafia. I'm going to say the same back to you, you're good at being scum.
I never put anything on you, all I ever did was suspected you. I’m not going to repeat what I said, but I still stand by it.
MorRioghan wrote on 2019-04-15 11:46:39:
@/EmbertheSkyWing I don't understand why Sky would either, unless she's just playing chess with us all. I believe her, it's the only thing that makes sense.
You tried to catch me in the act of something I didn't do. I'm not lying. I'm town and I'm only trying to come up with theories that make sense. (1) So far, the only one I've found that really does is that you're the transporter. That's it. I'm really hoping you're not town and that somehow Sky has fooled us both, but I just can't see that being true. (1)
The only thing that makes sense is that you're mafia.
@/SkyDancer10 Ember tried and failed to get me to make a mistake somewhere that she could use against me. The problem is, I wasn't lying. I think she was hoping I would word something differently or leave out a part or something I don't know. I wouldn't know, I'm not lying. (2) I want to win this for the town. My story has stayed the same because my story is the truth. Please, trust that.
So was I. (1)
Can you rephrase this? (2)
If I knew that you weren’t lying, why the heck would I even try it? That technique is used to out liars by making them tell the story they made up backwards. I wasn’t sure if it would work in a forum, but it was worth a try. (3)
.......
