i am once again asking what "excessive violence" actually entails. I don't think we've ever received a verdict that wasn't so subjective as to be entirely worthless and unenforceable... idk like... what's the point in a rule if it's so incredibly unspecific. like...
is allowed even though that skin is probably the msot visually horrifying thing ever, but that's a 2020 skin so it must be okay, so where do certain older skins lie?
this one has bones and rended flesh, is this still okay? sure looks painful and rather like suffering, yknow, if you imagine it that way..
...I'm not saying guro should be allowed, i only want rules that make sense, and I want consistency within those rules. you could like... give clearly defined examples in the official rule as a start? idk man, I've been thinking about it since october.
I think part of the problem is that there is canon violence but we're only selectively allowed to visually depict it. what vague and ill-defined rules regarding visual violence are contradicted by canon lore. if there were a skin made where thorny vines pierce a dragon's flesh and it was made reasonably realistic, like you can see that there is a grievous wound, would that be acceptable? that's a thing that canonically happened, so can you visually express it? is
acceptable? you can argue that when it's visual its worse, but is that really true? when you read a book, do you not imagine the contents with your minds eye? when it's purely visual, you only have what you see so you can pretend it isn't painful. there's no character attached to it, there's no emotional connection, but when you read it, your imagination is likely to go wild specifically because you have am emotional connection with the character, that's just how your brain works. either way, it's subjective and different for everyone.
before anyone gets up my butt about it, I can't believe it really needs to be said but i hold nothing against any artists on the site whatsoever. that ear skin makes me physically nauseous, but it doesn't for everyone. plague primal makes others feel sick, but I love it.
that's why rules need to be really specific and consistent because what's squicky is different for everyone.
hope my thought-vomit made any sense. I'm sure i'm gonna get some response to this so just keep in mind that I will block you if you're rude.