so, as with everyone, obviously this is entirely based on my own personal style, but...
S-Tier
nature:
special competition "bye" due to it being in my personal contract that if there's a plant faction i just Gotta. I joined as Nature and I'll never leave. (...never leave but always leaf.)
A-Tier
light: perpetually elegant knowledge-seekers in a timeless landscape that hides a history as cursed as it is ancient? nice. plus, the eyes would work with even more of my pairs than Nature's do.
shadow: this flight's lore is honestly my heartsong; I've made it so my clan has heavy scary fairy vibes with its lore, but Shadow has that all built in. love a good glowing mushroom too. honestly I'd have moved there by now if I didn't..... dislike purple that isn't very light/dark. womp womp.
earth: after the BotE update, this flight has my overall favorite eyes—even more so now that i've gotten into dragons in brown and swampy shades. it also seems to have a really solid community (including my wife!).
B-Tier
wind: light green is my favorite color; also the flight has my favorite deity design. the lore isn't really my vibe though.
plague: sister flight! way less my aesthetic than Nature is, and the red eyes would really throw a wrench into my breeding pairs, but Plaguelings are just. really cool people. big lesbian energy, too.
C-Tier
ice: very flexible eye color to work with. wardens of ancient evil are neat.
arcane: honestly one of my favorite lore flights on the site, and the one that I at least initially thought would be the best match for my personality (intellectual curiosity and an affinity for the strange). ultimately, though, the pink eyes are hard to work with, and other flights have since eclipsed Arcane in how connected I feel to their lore.
D-Tier
Lightning: the eyes are real pretty...... and the lore is literally the extreme polar opposite of my aesthetic.
Fire: no personal connection to the lore or the aesthetic. flamemom is a certified hottie, though. (/rimshot.)
Water: the oracular angle and the mysterious nature of the Tidelord are both really neat, but I don't like sapphire blue as a color at all, and that alone ensures water is at the bottom of my list.
nature:
special competition "bye" due to it being in my personal contract that if there's a plant faction i just Gotta. I joined as Nature and I'll never leave. (...never leave but always leaf.)
A-Tier
light: perpetually elegant knowledge-seekers in a timeless landscape that hides a history as cursed as it is ancient? nice. plus, the eyes would work with even more of my pairs than Nature's do.
shadow: this flight's lore is honestly my heartsong; I've made it so my clan has heavy scary fairy vibes with its lore, but Shadow has that all built in. love a good glowing mushroom too. honestly I'd have moved there by now if I didn't..... dislike purple that isn't very light/dark. womp womp.
earth: after the BotE update, this flight has my overall favorite eyes—even more so now that i've gotten into dragons in brown and swampy shades. it also seems to have a really solid community (including my wife!).
B-Tier
wind: light green is my favorite color; also the flight has my favorite deity design. the lore isn't really my vibe though.
plague: sister flight! way less my aesthetic than Nature is, and the red eyes would really throw a wrench into my breeding pairs, but Plaguelings are just. really cool people. big lesbian energy, too.
C-Tier
ice: very flexible eye color to work with. wardens of ancient evil are neat.
arcane: honestly one of my favorite lore flights on the site, and the one that I at least initially thought would be the best match for my personality (intellectual curiosity and an affinity for the strange). ultimately, though, the pink eyes are hard to work with, and other flights have since eclipsed Arcane in how connected I feel to their lore.
D-Tier
Lightning: the eyes are real pretty...... and the lore is literally the extreme polar opposite of my aesthetic.
Fire: no personal connection to the lore or the aesthetic. flamemom is a certified hottie, though. (/rimshot.)
Water: the oracular angle and the mysterious nature of the Tidelord are both really neat, but I don't like sapphire blue as a color at all, and that alone ensures water is at the bottom of my list.