Astr0fish wrote on 2020-06-08 08:19:21:
Celeana wrote on 2020-06-08 08:18:33:
Amayai wrote on 2020-06-08 06:59:08:
Apparel being the first thing you see in the dragon's page? 0/10. From a design perspective, your eye enters the dragon page from the apparel. It's not so bad because it seems constrained to the bottom left area, which is gestalt-wise the least important and memorable, but it's certainly not more important than the dragon's info (hatchday, length, genes), which got renegated to the bottom row. Apparel is unimportant unless a viewer is specifically looking for a piece's name, and it's redundant to have apparel and the dragon wearing the apparel in the same "most important" row of the profile page.
My point: Apparel and dragon info should switch places. The rest of the revamp is absolutely gorgeous. But apparel is not important enough to be the first thing you see in a dragon's page, besides being redundant since the dragon's image is already wearing the apparel.
I agree with this, especially on dragons that are wearing little or no apparel, so all I see are a bunch of dashed squares.
I'd much rather see the genes, tbh. I know you wanted "customizable" things towards the top, but when I look at other people's lairs, it's the genes that I'm probably going to be looking at, which is hard enough if they have 10 slots of apparel over them. And isn't customizing the genes a bigger part of the game than apparel, since the genes are what gets passed on to the hatchlings?
Here's my suggestion:
Top row: dragon info, dragon, familiar
Middle row: apparel, lineage, battle info? That way, the two items with pictures can be on the outside edges, with the progeny list to divide them and balance them out.
Sorry to sound kind of negative. I love everything else that you unveiled today, and I appreciate your hard work year round. Being able to see the battle stats is going to make everyone's life a lot easier. And there have been a lot of great developments this year - The Game Database is golden! And a Lovecraftian coli venue? Count me in! But I'm just a bit bummed about this since this change so prominent in game play.
100% agree with this. Its a lot of clutter in a small amount of space, and its pretty hard to read.
urgh yes! and not only the clutter but the dotted lines are not a good choice, ive seen it mentioned that it makes the page feel like its constantly in an edit mode, and shows up with no familiar too. You put a giant dotted box next to the dragon that screams hey!!! put something here!!! like the dragon's profile is incomplete without filling all apparel slots and having a familiar. an empty box should NOT be the first thing you look at.
i also kinda was partial to the off-white yellowy color of the prior layout, it was definitely warmer and prettier to look at, though the scenes kinda fix this