Edit: Feel free to add your own feedbacks and criticism. PLEASE be nice to people with differing opinions. This is supposed to help staff with their creation, be able to see if any of the things need fixing. This is not to bash on each other for different views on the changes!
Not sure how to feel about being redirected to "Suggestions" for feedback but here I go:
First of, the alignment of all the elements looks just sightly out of place when you look at the whole picture instead of going by column. I adjusted my profile text in a way so the end of my text aligns with the ID-Card thing.
Second - if you use the maximum space of the profile text, it ends super weirdly not quite aligned with the friend's list. It's just pixels off but it looks weird. Aswell as the comment box + headline being unaligned towards anything anchored.
Next up are the headlines "x's Friends", "Recent Forum Posts" and "Recent Activity", they look lost without a clear frame or box. Just adding one little line makes them look less floating in space.
In the preview that was shown in the thread the Posts and Activity have slightly grey boxes (instead of text because no activity) and maybe having that as a background for the text might also help with less floaty elements (instead of the line).
I also changed the order of the elements because I disliked the Image (ID-card), text (forum posts), image (friends), text (activity log) and this looks less cluttered to me but that might just be preference.
Now we have to talk about the colors. The overall theme is the lightgrey used as lines and under the comment box where the wordcount is. Why are the comment boxes orange? In the preview you showed they were grey (for profiles without comments) and it looks way more matchy because it's more consistent.
Also the way colors are handled. For this I used someone else's post in the announcement thread I hope thats fine, because it explains what I mean:
The last thing are the comments. The names are way too big, even the code agrees because on letters like g it just get's cut off by the line with the date the comment was posted:
The buttons feel too big too, all in all the comments are with the background color, the huge font and the big icons a bit too 'in your face'.
Now seriously the last thing but the ID Card looks empty on the left now that the birthday is gone :/
Not sure how to feel about being redirected to "Suggestions" for feedback but here I go:
First of, the alignment of all the elements looks just sightly out of place when you look at the whole picture instead of going by column. I adjusted my profile text in a way so the end of my text aligns with the ID-Card thing.
Second - if you use the maximum space of the profile text, it ends super weirdly not quite aligned with the friend's list. It's just pixels off but it looks weird. Aswell as the comment box + headline being unaligned towards anything anchored.
Next up are the headlines "x's Friends", "Recent Forum Posts" and "Recent Activity", they look lost without a clear frame or box. Just adding one little line makes them look less floating in space.
In the preview that was shown in the thread the Posts and Activity have slightly grey boxes (instead of text because no activity) and maybe having that as a background for the text might also help with less floaty elements (instead of the line).
I also changed the order of the elements because I disliked the Image (ID-card), text (forum posts), image (friends), text (activity log) and this looks less cluttered to me but that might just be preference.
Now we have to talk about the colors. The overall theme is the lightgrey used as lines and under the comment box where the wordcount is. Why are the comment boxes orange? In the preview you showed they were grey (for profiles without comments) and it looks way more matchy because it's more consistent.
Also the way colors are handled. For this I used someone else's post in the announcement thread I hope thats fine, because it explains what I mean:
cross wrote on 2022-10-03 07:56:34:
i'm glad about more frequent UI changes, but i have some issues with the cohesion of the new clan profile layout. hopefully this explains my thoughts
i really wish every text box was the same. right now it just has a lot of different design attributes at once.
i really wish every text box was the same. right now it just has a lot of different design attributes at once.
The last thing are the comments. The names are way too big, even the code agrees because on letters like g it just get's cut off by the line with the date the comment was posted:
The buttons feel too big too, all in all the comments are with the background color, the huge font and the big icons a bit too 'in your face'.
Now seriously the last thing but the ID Card looks empty on the left now that the birthday is gone :/
