brokenstone wrote on 2018-01-04:
I was actually talking with a friend just now that it is only lvl + 2 added. So 27 points added from a lvl 25 rally, 22 points added from a lvl 22 rally. And it makes sense pointwise since at first each point adds 5 dmg, but it scales down as you put more into STR (eg you only get 4 per point)
@
brokenstone Hi, I am so sorry to jump in. I hope this information can help, as I have seen evidence that buffs really do, in fact, give +30 stats at level 25. I tested each buff thoroughly a few years ago before listing the effects in
my skills and monsters guide, and Maki's
battle stones guide also includes information that is in agreement. Maki does a lot more thorough testing on Coliseum issues than I do and has often helped to spot discrepancies in the info, and I personally trust Maki's information to be accurate.
Just in case things changed from 2013, I performed tests just today to check, and my tests today have confirmed that the buff effects still give +30 stats at level 25.
Here is some evidence from my tests that I performed a few minutes ago!
---
First I will show you the effects of Rallied Scratch and Rallied Eliminate on a Common Podid, where the numbers match up exactly with the formulae in my damage guide as well as the predicted damage for 147 (117 STR + 30 STR from Rally) in the skill calculator. I will provide a screenshot of my dragon's stats and stones too.
117 STR + Rally 30 STR Scratch deals 540 damage to Common Podid.
117 STR + Rally 30 STR Eliminate deals 1659 damage to Common Podid.
Dragon's stats and stones show he has 117 STR
Rally tooltip agrees with damage numbers and shows a buff of 30 STR
Here are the other buffs that are not rally, showing tooltips also buffing 30 of each stat
Haste
Bolster
Concentration
Ward
I hope these help to show that a level 25 buff will truly provide a buff equivalent to level + 5.
---
For the discussion of 119 STR vs. 117 STR, I did speed tests in the past to compare the two. My conclusion was that the times were very similar and it's really up to personal preference which build is used.
Being able to Rally + Eliminate everything is a charm of 119 STR (and it works nicely if you want to mix things up with Anticipate).
I use 117 STR because weaving in the extra Scratch on Brilliant Psywurm and Mossy Cerdae offers an alternate skill "rotation" that generates more breath as a buffer for missing. Cutting out the Rally for those also reduces casting time. When Coliseum 2.0 comes out, I will re-take my speed tests because
buff animation time will be significantly reduced according to a very recent announcement by the devs. If they are reworking AGI to be better, the misses might also be reduced. These two changes combined would likely make the advantages of 117 STR go away, and I will likely shift to 119 STR after some conclusive testing.
Here is my raw data from 2016 for speed tests.
117 STR speed tests
119 STR speed tests
Level 4 had 312 tests for 117 STR and 126 tests for 119 STR. The level 4 times for 117 STR and 119 STR, respectively, were 33 seconds vs. 32 seconds per dragon.
Level 5 had 310 tests for 117 STR and 124 tests for 119 STR. The level 5 times for 117 STR and 119 STR were equal at 1 minute 10 seconds per dragon.
Level 6 had 276 tests for 117 STR and 124 tests for 119 STR. The level 6 times for 117 STR and 119 STR were 1 minute 56 seconds vs. 1 minute 59 seconds per dragon.
(I do more speed tests than these, but these are the most relevant to the current discussion.) I have found that it takes
at least 200 tests per level for the average times to not sway multiple seconds if RNG causes a particularly fast or particularly slow trial to get added to the average. There is also the caveat that these tests were taken in 2016, after the monster packs were "finalized" - no significant changes have been made to monsters from then till now - but before the Mire was bumped to the second page of the Coliseum, which very slightly affects refresh times. (If there is a difference between refresh frequency for 117 STR build and 119 STR build, this could manifest with the second page issue.)
Anyway, I think both builds are equally good and it is fine for someone to use either build depending on their playstyle. :)