I swear, I looked through the player list and I did not see the weird number 10! I do not know why I missed it. My programming should have detected an anomaly in the listing of players. Perhaps I am becoming more human after all, as they seem to be more prone to error than I am.
As I go through the thread I am going to list what everybody has done so far and write my observations and notes about them. If you're not on the list I have no thoughts on you yet.
TyrianCallows- First to post- that does not mean anything really. Fluffed when answering the question on Day One lynching. I find that strange. It could just be that they were having fun getting into character, but I would also think that you would want people to know what your genuine thoughts were on important discussions such as the subject on day one lynching, so you would want to be serious. Poked inactives.
MagykalWagykal- Suggested that everybody ask their own questions instead of having one person write a big questionnaire. Is for day one lynches and explained their reasoning. Seems to post a lot but has good points.
StormDreamer- Explained their reasoning for day one lynches pretty well.
Lyxla- Her first few posts seem kind of weird to me but I also get the feeling that she is extremely new to mafia. But I am not going to let her "slide" because of that. She does not just give out a "newbie" vibe to me, she gives off a "newbie that just got mafia and does not know what to do". I do not know, I do not think we should go off vibes but I was wondering if anybody agreed with me there.
Shadowlugia711- For day one lynching. Asked if we should try to guess other people's characters. This could be an attempt to predict a player's abilities based on their character in order to see which players could be a good target for mafia, but, I highly doubt it. Still I feel that I should put that out there. I wonder what others think. Seems nervous but I think that is roleplaying. But generally seems like they do not want to mess anything up.
Quamosthy- They answered the d1 lynch question by saying what they heard others in a game say about it. I am not sure what to think of it. They also seemed to not agree with Tyrian poking the inactives? They say the vocal ones can be just a likely to be scum, which is true, but why did they react the way they did when Tyrian tried to get the inactives talking? I am curious.
Cognitive- Gave a good first post.
Amapup- Also had a good first post, and was the first to bring up the number 10. I had not even considered looking at the player list and I do not think anybody else did either. They also started to discuss with BerryBagel which I do like but I do not think is indicative of town or scum as I believe Amapup is more experienced.
LordMalak- If I were capable of emotion I WOULD LOVE DIS DOKTOR! Okay but seriously, their first post says that they will not argue if town decides to lynch on Day One because the rest of the players are probably more experienced than them. That kind of implies, to me, that they will let the rest of town lead. That can be a problem, as you are never certain who is town in this game, and you could easily be misled by someone you think is an experienced town leader and is actually mafia. I feel that it is not a problem to "go with the flow" IF you truly agree with the majority, but try to still be an individual and form your own opinions about things.
Agrina- Hello I was in the first Fandom Mafia game with you so I know exactly how you should act. I remember in the first game you were the one making the very long posts (also I accidentally outed you and I am still very sorry about that). You seem to be making shorter posts and that is strange. I can not recall if I was ever in a game with you other than Fandom Mafia so I do not know what is normal for you. I am not saying short posts is scummy or anything. Just strange. Also you are just not contributing much to the conversation as much as I thought you would be. I understand if you are tired for the first day and I will let that go, but if you are not more involved in the future I will be suspicious.
VivaFariy- Gave brief and vague answers to the questions in their first post, but also suggested a possible explanation of the number 10 in the player list. Does a lot of fluffing the first day but that is to be expected in this kind of game, and also not a lot to go on for day one anyways. As for her ability, there is a 72.85% chance that her ability is strength related due to her character, but I also think that there is the possibility that her ability could be related to her character but not in the way we think- as in, not strength related.
Ravenwolf- Gave a brief first post but okay and asked their own question.
Wyxamex- My only question is why you believe number 10 is bad. I do not think you are going to answer that.
SilverMoonfire- What kind of first post was that. Hwat. I do not even know why you say that, the scum-hunting and finger pointing had not even really begun when you posted that. I am just very confused? Maybe that is just part of their character they are roleplaying. Probably. Still do not seem to contribute very much though and that is problematic.
I will be honest. This is just my thoughts from the first 10 pages. My positronic brain is fried (not literally. I hope I am using the human expression correctly) I am going to be taking a break before doing any more searching through the thread. As I said before, since I only deeply looked through the fist 10 pages, the concerns I brought up may have been resolved by now. So do not bother to correct me. I will see the rest of the thread later.
As I go through the thread I am going to list what everybody has done so far and write my observations and notes about them. If you're not on the list I have no thoughts on you yet.
TyrianCallows- First to post- that does not mean anything really. Fluffed when answering the question on Day One lynching. I find that strange. It could just be that they were having fun getting into character, but I would also think that you would want people to know what your genuine thoughts were on important discussions such as the subject on day one lynching, so you would want to be serious. Poked inactives.
MagykalWagykal- Suggested that everybody ask their own questions instead of having one person write a big questionnaire. Is for day one lynches and explained their reasoning. Seems to post a lot but has good points.
StormDreamer- Explained their reasoning for day one lynches pretty well.
Lyxla- Her first few posts seem kind of weird to me but I also get the feeling that she is extremely new to mafia. But I am not going to let her "slide" because of that. She does not just give out a "newbie" vibe to me, she gives off a "newbie that just got mafia and does not know what to do". I do not know, I do not think we should go off vibes but I was wondering if anybody agreed with me there.
Shadowlugia711- For day one lynching. Asked if we should try to guess other people's characters. This could be an attempt to predict a player's abilities based on their character in order to see which players could be a good target for mafia, but, I highly doubt it. Still I feel that I should put that out there. I wonder what others think. Seems nervous but I think that is roleplaying. But generally seems like they do not want to mess anything up.
Quamosthy- They answered the d1 lynch question by saying what they heard others in a game say about it. I am not sure what to think of it. They also seemed to not agree with Tyrian poking the inactives? They say the vocal ones can be just a likely to be scum, which is true, but why did they react the way they did when Tyrian tried to get the inactives talking? I am curious.
Cognitive- Gave a good first post.
Amapup- Also had a good first post, and was the first to bring up the number 10. I had not even considered looking at the player list and I do not think anybody else did either. They also started to discuss with BerryBagel which I do like but I do not think is indicative of town or scum as I believe Amapup is more experienced.
LordMalak- If I were capable of emotion I WOULD LOVE DIS DOKTOR! Okay but seriously, their first post says that they will not argue if town decides to lynch on Day One because the rest of the players are probably more experienced than them. That kind of implies, to me, that they will let the rest of town lead. That can be a problem, as you are never certain who is town in this game, and you could easily be misled by someone you think is an experienced town leader and is actually mafia. I feel that it is not a problem to "go with the flow" IF you truly agree with the majority, but try to still be an individual and form your own opinions about things.
Agrina- Hello I was in the first Fandom Mafia game with you so I know exactly how you should act. I remember in the first game you were the one making the very long posts (also I accidentally outed you and I am still very sorry about that). You seem to be making shorter posts and that is strange. I can not recall if I was ever in a game with you other than Fandom Mafia so I do not know what is normal for you. I am not saying short posts is scummy or anything. Just strange. Also you are just not contributing much to the conversation as much as I thought you would be. I understand if you are tired for the first day and I will let that go, but if you are not more involved in the future I will be suspicious.
VivaFariy- Gave brief and vague answers to the questions in their first post, but also suggested a possible explanation of the number 10 in the player list. Does a lot of fluffing the first day but that is to be expected in this kind of game, and also not a lot to go on for day one anyways. As for her ability, there is a 72.85% chance that her ability is strength related due to her character, but I also think that there is the possibility that her ability could be related to her character but not in the way we think- as in, not strength related.
Ravenwolf- Gave a brief first post but okay and asked their own question.
Wyxamex- My only question is why you believe number 10 is bad. I do not think you are going to answer that.
SilverMoonfire- What kind of first post was that. Hwat. I do not even know why you say that, the scum-hunting and finger pointing had not even really begun when you posted that. I am just very confused? Maybe that is just part of their character they are roleplaying. Probably. Still do not seem to contribute very much though and that is problematic.
I will be honest. This is just my thoughts from the first 10 pages. My positronic brain is fried (not literally. I hope I am using the human expression correctly) I am going to be taking a break before doing any more searching through the thread. As I said before, since I only deeply looked through the fist 10 pages, the concerns I brought up may have been resolved by now. So do not bother to correct me. I will see the rest of the thread later.