Planete wrote on 2019-03-28 09:42:28:
I love both a lot.
- Random for the surprise, i would have loved FR going even more in that direction but understand that players who have breeding projects prefer to avoid "bad surprises". As a procedural generation and randomization "nerd" I want the surprises and the lack of control, but i get it.
- Breeding-only for the variety in gameplay, and the extra-value accorded to breeders and young dragons, while now Gen1 and low-digits are the only dragons who are worth anything long-term. And my "hatch a nest a day" play style is not rewarding in game aside from the "fun" value i give it.
Woah, whoah, woah, I love randomness myself. I try to create randomness, most of my pairs are non-matching with genes that have contrast colors (Lionfish,Poison,Skink,Tapir) because I love the kinds of random colors I get. I rarely have ZZ-breed pairs because when I throw my mirror and imp together, I'm still waiting for them to make an imp baby so I can add it to lore. When that baby arrives it's going to be me waiting for 4 years of waiting on RNG to pay off and in the meantime, I love the colorful random babies they throw the rest of the time.
If you can't figure out how to enjoy random eye-breeding results, while other people customize their old dragons, then the problem is the constraints you've applied to your own playstyle. You mentioned earlier that 'what's the point if you can buy what you want?' I don't think you remember that eyes aren't controllable, offer no dragon-benefit, and can't be bred for. Me having a vial for Goat or
Omega or
Cuttlefish or anything new they pull out doesn't change your chances of hatching a Primal from a clashy fodder pair or never getting Dark Sclera by random chance. The ability for me to buy a UM skin for big cat stripes to put on a dragon I've bought Spiral for, doesn't stop you breeding Obs Tiger Common X Copper Iri Uncommon together and getting a Sand Tiger Faceted baby "randomly".
But that's sort of the vibe I get from your arguments. No one should have vials, because
you want pure random, random you are still going to get regardless, just like everyone's going to get random results in their nests and G1 eggs. But because other people want to reskin their results, they shouldn't be able to, because if you could reskin, you wouldn't bother. That makes no sense as an argument. If you don't want to use vials, don't. Please, if you enjoy Randomness, then take up a breeding challenge. Take triple-basic G1 starters and breed them into XXX imperials with Facet. There is going to be plenty of random in that (I've done it for kicks, not to the Imperial level, but for genes and it is interesting what colors you get.)
I had a similar argument to this once in Suggestions. I wanted a toggle option to show adults in the Forsee Progeny scryer. My logic was, dragons are adults a lot longer than they are hatchlings and certain genes change between hatchling and adult stages, so, seeing if offspring would show desired patterns better as adults would help me guide my breeding plans. Another user claimed that somehow, being able to see adults in the scryer would ruin their playstyle and it shouldn't be a thing. According to them, you either knew exactly what you were going to get (breeding XXXs) or you didn't care what the results were (if you bred XYZ) and you should be patient since what difference did it make. Or, I should take every color/gene option and scry it manually using the tools already in place, instead of asking for a simple opt-in-to-use function. In a toggle, an optional toggle that the other user was in no way obliged to use. That argument was palpably ridiculous.
TL:DR The fun of FR is making your own fun and that everyone can make their fun without interfering with the fun of other players. Make up your lair's rules and go from there, stop expecting to be stopped or constrained by the game's external controls. But it should be up to the user to be able to make those choices. In the current Eyedebacle, no player can 'make their own fun', we no longer have choices. Their fun is a progen with Primal. Not getting it. Their fun is Goat on an Buffy The Vampire fandragon, they can't having it.
Your fun? Random eyes on every breeding and no way for anyone to change it. You're the only one having fun right now. Where does that leave everyone else?